Craft Whisky Club Reviews 

Very prompt delivery, loved our first bottle and snacks can't wait for our next bottle! I purchased one club for my husband and one for our son in Boston. We are doing FaceTime tastings together. This has been fun and we all really thought the quality of the first package was excellent. Thanks!

Both whiskies were excellent. I also enjoyed the Glencairn glass from Westward and the chocolates as nice surprise additions!

The box I got in the mail was fantastic. A great whiskey and some excellent pairings in a really nice package.

I bought a gift subscription for my husband’s birthday. The whisky and glass were really good but he didn’t think the snacks were suitable for having with a dram but that could just be his taste as he prefers savoury and the snacks were sweet. It’s a nice gift though and he would never have bought the whisky that came as he’s a Speyside malt drinker so at least it broadened his horizons!

The delivery was great. The packaging ensured the contents were safe and secure. The glass was a nice surprise. The big downside was the whiskey was insanely strong.

Hoping for more whiskeys outside the US. Good overall for a Kentucky bourbon.

I got this as a gift from my wife. It is awesome! The whiskey are great picks, and the extras that come with it have been great. The info sent went each makes the bottle almost personal to the person. Thank Craft Whiskey Club!

Edited: The second delivery came with a can of pecans and a single glass with a Campari brand engraved on it. It's weird enough getting one glass. Getting one engraved with a brand of Campari is a different level of weird. I will say that the whiskey they sent has been 'high octane, so if that's your goal in a whiskey subscription, you might like this. I ordered a subscription - 3 bottles delivered in 6 months. So far, the first two bottles have been American whiskeys. That's not what I was hoping for. With all the pictures of Scottish and Irish whisky I was hoping for at least one that wasn't American. I guess we'll see with the third one. Don't really think it was a good value.

Great whisky, nicely curated package. Looking forward to the next one.

We have only had one bottle so far, but it was tasty and previously unknown to us! The club was gift so we did not go through the buying process itself, but having done delivery alcohol programs before, we much appreciate the challenges to delivery to our state, and how smoothly that went when we started indicates a lot of organization and thoughtful detail to providing a good customer experience.

Great products! Can’t wait for my next shipment.

I like this whiskey a lot, it was smooth and mellow with backgrounds of smoky orange and dark chocolate. Excellent packaging and accompaniments. I would definitely recommend this product.

An excellent Christmas present. I like the extra biscuits, glass and hot chocolate.

The only improvement for me would be a quarterly option for delivery.

Great job with the items select it... for the whiskey club.. I’m going to enjoy this months and try out this new glass that came with my whiskey. So far it’s been great..

Wonderful quality whiskey. Great customer service also! Looking forward to the next bottle we receive!
Happy New Year!

My husband loved this gift. It arrived earlier than expected, was packaged perfectly and came with a full sized bottle, chocolate and tasting glass. It exceeded my expectations!

It was not possible to give you a higher rating after just one delivery.

Craft Whisky Club claims that they will enable you on your journey to discovering some of the world's craft distillers. In fact, your "journey" is really not yours. It's whoever picked out a bottle of craft whisky and sent it to you in the hopes that it will be a fantastic new discovery. But not all whiskies work for everyone. I was hoping that my "journey" would have started by providing a set of samples from which I could start or continue my craft whisky journey so that I have control over the bottle I would next receive. Instead, my journey is left up to the curators at the Club and I (hopefully) have a bottle that works for my tastes and palate...or that ends up in the back of my liquor cabinet to be used in cocktails.

I was also hoping for (but do not get access to) some type of forum where members can discuss different discussion topics such as whisky reviews, ideas to make a more memorable membership, feedback to the different distillers and the value of the overall experience. Individual member experiences are good, but sharing member experiences is much better - e.g. someone may have posted a tasting note about a craft whisky that I hadn't quite picked up the first time, but can look forward to with my next pour.

I was also confounded by the pricing of a whisky available in the Secret Still shop. Price in their shop was US$48 MORE than what I could purchase from my shop down the street. I do not consider the Secret Still Shop price fair and reasonable, leading me to question the pricing in that shop altogether. But that was just for one bottle and may not be indicative of all available bottles from their online shop.

Sent a great single malt whiskey. It was nice to try something new as a newbie.They delivered quickly and updated me on what was happening. They were also easy to get a hold of and answered all my questions timely. We are looking forward to the next month!

My husband was very happy to receive this subscription as his Christmas gift and is looking forward to new arrivals throughout the year!