Mtgproxy Reviews 635

I ordered my second round of cards from mtgproxy.com after seeing my first order. The cards came out looking and feeling great. I’ve had several people inspect them and comment on the excellent quality. I have made sure to order more than 200 cards at a time to ensure .75¢ per card.

I can assure you I’ll be using them for all my proxy needs!!

Thank you MTGPROXY.COM

I've ordered proxy cards from here a few times now, and they always arrive in a timely manner with everything I ordered. I have mostly positive things to say, but here are some pros and cons.

Pros: Visually, they're exactly what you see on screen when I ordered them. Nicely centered, good clarity of text and art. Once sleeved, they look just like the real deal, it's great if you're going for visual accuracy on your proxies!

Cons: All of my cards have come with a curve to them. I'm not sure if this is intentional, or part of their printing process, or whatever, but it's a bit annoying. Not a dealbreaker though. They also don't feel like magic cards at all. The texture is more like a smooth, glossy feeling when you rub your finger over it. Similar to a dry-erase board.

The foils are also just okay. They don't blow me away, but there's nothing wrong with them. A bit expensive to do for the average look of them. Very reflective as well, I can literally see myself reflected on the card.

Overall though, I like these proxies. Once they're sleeved, it's just like playing a normal magic deck. I recommend :)

They are very communicative when things are shipping, when they should arrive, and the process in between! The cards I ordered in the booster packs were some VERY powerful cards, and I have since built decks around some of these cards! I can’t recommend them enough!

I have ordered from MTGProxy a couple of times now. I like building my decks around themes, and being able to make a proxy of a card to fit that theme is my favored method of building (especially when I don't have to worry about the price of the card). Typically I order large amount of proxies so their discount system based off of order size works great for me.

I've gone back to them because they do such a fine job that it makes the whole process easier for me and the quality is wonderful. I'll be coming back again in the future.

Fast shipping, and the quality of the cards are top tier! I've ordered from many different proxy sites and the folks at MTGProxy have got it right.

Great proxies and great experience every time!

Fast delivery all the way to the UK
Great points, better than some offal cards
Awesome alternatives to sleeving too

The quality of the product was amazing. The production was fast and the service was excellent

I’ve ordered from them before. Proxies were exactly what I needed, and shipping was quick!

Service is fantastic, they produce a high quality product where I legitimately have to label each card as a proxy otherwise I would have no idea which cards are real and which cards are proxies once they are sleeved and in my commander decks. Fantastic for a place holder as you slowly try to buy the real versions of cards. 10/10 would recommend this company

Whenever I place an order it is done quickly and is high quality. The ordering is easy and you have numerous options for the cards. Great place for proxies.

Like the title states. Simply the best quality in the proxy market. Artwork is crisp and clear, the font is easy to read, colors are brilliant. I have placed several orders over the last 6 months totaling over 200 cards, and each one has been 100% spot on. Thank you MTGproxy, I WILL be doing business again.

Great quality, good service to get when you want to play the game but can't afford the prices for the real cards.

Lots of options for many different arts, and you can create your own cards as well. The UI is very simple and I had no issues ordering the cards. It took about 5-6 days for the cards to arrive and I am very happy with how they look

If it wasn't for MTG Proxy I would not be buying magic cards often or at all for that matter. They help a LOT in cutting the costs down with really good art styles and quality.

I love the percentage of quality they added for each card art, I love how simple, clean and easy the interface is, and the options are wonderful.

I've purchased from them several times, and we'll go back for more. Definitely create an account to save your creations, but even then They have a restore feature in case you closed the tab.

Fantastic affordable company. Get over 200+ for that awesome discount and let's all have some good fun!

Great proxies and great experience every time!

Having built more than 2 dozen Commander Decks in recent memory, you don't always want to re-purchase those high dollar cards over and over again. Having some high-quality proxies to take their place when you need is definitely a plus!

Thanks again guys!

I have used them multiple for large and small proxy orders. They are great. Good quality, super easy to use.

Good looking proxies, fast delivery, order was all there!

There is very little bad I have to say about MTGProxy. The most minor criticism I have is that the margins on the cards are not communicated in a way that makes it obvious what they are there for. That's so minor in comparison to the quality of the product however. The foils end up looking gorgeous, the printing is as high quality as an actual card, and there's no smudging or smearing of any ink at all. Want a double-faced card? Easy, done. My Avatar Aang looks incredible and they didn't even charge me extra for it. The prices are super affordable and extremely reasonable too, which really lets basically anyone get the proxies they want and helps to keep Magic a game that you don't have to spend massive money on. I'm very impressed by the work that they do and will continue to come to them when I want to make my decks pretty and reference some of my favorite art.