Deceptive grading and damaged goods
Deceptive grading and damaged goods – Look under the screen protector!
I ordered an iPhone 15 Pro Max in "Excellent" condition via Reebelo, which was fulfilled and shipped directly by Bloombird Pty Ltd (trading as Perfect Pre Owned).
When the phone arrived, it had a cheap screen protector pre-installed. Knowing this is a common tactic used to mask display defects, I inspected the raw glass underneath. The bare screen has multiple deep, structurally tactile gouges and severe pitting. There are so many grooves and pits in the glass that you literally feel them dragging against your thumb multiple times every single time you scroll a webpage.
To call a device with physical glass fractures "Excellent" is absurd; it doesn't even meet a "Fair" standard. Slapping a screen protector over the top to hide this damage from a consumer during unboxing is deceptive, dishonest, and a clear breach of Australian Consumer Law guarantees regarding acceptable quality.
I have initiated a dispute and provided comprehensive photo and video evidence of the non-conformance. Because of the deceptive condition of this device and the administrative delays, I am demanding a full refund and will not accept a replacement from this vendor. I am currently waiting for them to log into the Reebelo merchant portal to issue my official return shipping label.
If this is simply an isolated quality control failure by Bloombird Pty Ltd, I expect them to prove it by acting professionally and rectifying this immediately. Having a public relations team reply to these complaints with empty assurances—while offering no evidence of an actual resolution—is not going to fool anyone in this day and age.
If they do not resolve this by Monday, I will be escalating this as a formal fraud chargeback with my financial institution and lodging complaints with the ACCC and WA Consumer Protection.
Buyer beware: If you buy from them, remove the screen protector immediately and inspect the raw glass.








