Liberty Coin Reviews 

Easy navigating the website, no difference in price cash vs credit. You accept PayPal which is convenient. Great prices thank you.

Always consistent fast and reliable service.

I have two pending orders at this time. Liberty coin has kept me informed about the progress of my orders. I'm looking forward to receiving my coins shortly. A previous order was what I expected.

The coin I wanted was cheaper than the competition and I have delt with Liberty before

Fast response and got eaactly what I ordered.

One of the best retailers IMHO, one that has never failed me on any purchase both on items offered, prices, delivery, and customer service. All the above checked out once again on this purchase. Thank you once again for the great deal and great service!

First denied the order then was sent a copy of the order form they then sent me a fake coin 16 days later. Hope this keeps someone else from being scammed

Great customer service and consistent communications. Plus, pretty much the best prices available.

They declined my order, and refused to tell me why or provide an alternative to purchase. Basically called me a fraudster too in their explanation. I guess I'll give my dollars to someone else online who actually want it and don't accuse me of being a scammer. Which is too bad because these guys were recommended by a Youtuber I follow, Florida Stacker.

The prices are very reasonable compared to some other coin dealers.

They provide free shipping but you won't receive your order, very frustrating they didn't want to assist me as a customer anymore.

Untrustworthy organization and terrible customer service. Not doing business with Liberty Coins ever again.

Thank you very much ordering was very easy and smooth.

Liberty coin is always my go to, fast shipping, great service and great prices

Always fast shipping and great packaging. Prices are great too. Even though we are coasts apart I get my orders faster than from the east coast.

The prices are within range of the market price. The delivery service is excellent. The product is sent out within 3-5 business days after your payment has cleared. Your product is sent out by FedEx for free and signature is required. Liberty Coin is excellent precious coin company.

Simple to use, find products, and check out.

I received my first, and possibly last order on Saturday 5/23/26 and was totally disappointed in the quality of 3 out of the five coins. Please refer to order XXXXXX for five BU Random Date Silver Eagles. Of the five coins I would consider two of them (dated 2022 and 2013) to be BU quality. Regarding the other three coins, one has obvious toning or a stain (dated 2009), one is off color and has dirt or debris built up on the surface and around the edge (dated 2013), and the last one has scratches above the "IN GOD WE TRUST" (dated 2004). Those three coins are circulated and two of them would be considered culls in my opinion. I would like my money refunded or those three coins replaced with BU quality coins.

Since February 12th of this year, I have purchased $12,344.15 worth of silver from SD Bullion, Hero Bullion, and JM Bullion and have never been disappointed with the quality of those purchases. I realize that is not a huge amount compared to many of your sales, but for this retired Navy Submarine Vet it is a significant amount of investment. I intend on spending at least that much, if not more over the next six months.

I read reviews on TrustPilot, and researched other reviews on Liberty Coins before I placed my order for 5 BU coins as a test of quality, customer service, as well as processing and shipping time. The quality of three of the coins in this order is extremely disappointing with regards to what those reviews said about your organization. It is my hope that some type of error was made in shipping those three coins as BU quality. I would like a resolution to this situation as soon as possible so a review I will write on TrustPilot will be a positive one.

Please inform me of the process for returning all five coins and getting my money back or for replacing three of the five coins. I request a phone call to 308-289-4014 with a return authorization number and an address to return the entire order or the three coins that are not of BU quality.

They offered me a $10 refund on my order. No offer to return the coins. I will not be doing business with them again.