Craft Holsters Reviews 402

I am very very dissatisfied with their customer service:
- Customer service is extremely slow. It's not uncommon for it to take a week for a response
- Their return policy is misleading and impossible to satisfy. I purchased a mag pouch. None of my 9mm or 10mm mags fit. I requested a return and refund. They refused saying my mag pouch works for 9mm. Well my Glock mags don't fit.....

I'd stay away from this company. Very poor business practices.

Buy from Amazon. You can return your items if it doesn't work.

Only giving it a it might go up to a 2 once I receive the next holster. If it actually fits but ordered a specific holster for my sig. P226 now when I ordered the picture had the red dot cutout on it. So I assumed it was the correct one upon receiving it. It did not. So I contacted them to see about an exchange and was told they are unable to do that even though the product was in stock, they didn't make it custom. It was in stock, but they wouldn't accept the other one. Back to return made me pay another $81 to replace the holster. For the shoulder harness So I have nearly $300 and 1 shoulder harness. I think that is unacceptable and I will never buy anything from them again. I even offered to pay the shipping to ship it back to get the right one. And they still made me buy a whole nother holster.
I would advise strongly against dealing with them as the quality product isn't worth the cost. When you consider how much it actually cost me to get the holster I know. I will never shop with them again. They made no attempts to make it right.

My experience with Craft Holsters was excellent. The holster fit perfectly, feels sturdy, and the craftsmanship is top notch. Shipping was fast, and the service was professional.

At first I was disappointed with the product and bashed them on a review. Upon further study I realized the holster worked fine with the 1911 style pistol in the cocked position. My bad. So give them a try but study the pics closer!

I purchased Craft Holsters OWB Leather Pancake Holster w 2 Carry Positions. This is the best leather holster I ever purchased. Thier instruction videos on how to break-in the leather and how to care and treat the holster are excellent. I puchase it in black and I will be purchasing the same holster in tan. I highly recommend Craft Holsters.

I ordered a holster on 10/25/25 - it shipped out on 11/19/25 and I received it on 11/24/25 - when I placed the order I wasn't aware that it was coming from Europe but they did say it would take approx 30 days - the holster is made well and actually fits my pistol/light combo correctly - being hand-tooled leather it was VERY stiff and required significant break-in - after a week of conditioning the leather and sliding the weapon in and out numerous times, it's getting better - I'm happy with my purchase!

I received my holster today, and I am extremely impressed. I have been searching for a long time to find the right holster for this firearm, which holds great sentimental value as it was my grandfather’s favorite piece—a 1970s Colt Python. Until now, I had never been able to find a proper fit.

I opened it just a few minutes ago and was amazed at how perfect the fit is. It required no break-in period and looks outstanding. The way it slides in and out is flawless, and the precision right out of the box really exceeded my expectations. I especially appreciate being able to personalize it with my grandfather’s initials. That meant a great deal to me.

Truly above and beyond. Thank you again for your craftsmanship and attention to detail.

Craft holsters makes great quality holsters for a reasonable price. Just all around a great company with awesome products!

Very good quality and great customer service

I just received this item... Really impressed with the quality leather, great color, stitching is top notch, I was so upset the mags didn't seem to fit when I first tried to push them in the holder. Tight... That's expected so I spritzed the inside with the break in fluid. Re inserted the ill-fitting mags and left it overnight. That seemed to free things up but the mag on one side would hang while the other pulled out snug but not a problem. Here's the fix for my S&W M&P Shield single stack mags need to be inserted with the flat side of the heel in centered and the round side to the outside, this puts the hooks in the mag that grab the inside gun on the outside where the leather folds and is slightly shaped so to not hang. Retention screws will let you adjust the hold to avoid the mag slipping out. Once I got this resolved I just fidgeted with the mags in and out to where now everything fits snug not too tight and are easy to purposely remove and insert.

Very professional, great fit and realiable a must have.

Worth the wait!!! Great customer service and high quality leather compared to the ones I bought elsewhere. Other shoulder holsters ruined my expensive clothes & sweaters. The leather Craft Holsters’ Shoulder Holster for my 9mm firearm is awesome when using open carry and concealed carry, especially wearing a full dress. I don’t leave my firearm and mags inside a purse away from my body. The break-in kit will help fit your firearm inside the holster and you’ll need a larger size. I didn’t know what it is for so I got the tiny size but luckily I had leftover the one I got from Coach for my purse and used it on my Shoulder Holster. I always wear it open carry to stores/facilities allowing open carry and to the mountains. I will definitely order my future leather holsters for my next firearms from Craft Holsters.

When I opened the box containing my new holster it was the Thank You Card that immediately caught my eye. This was my first Craft Holster, and I cannot say how impressed I am with the craftsmanship and thought that went into this holster. Please keep up the high-quality product at a fair price. And for making it personal!

Great holster, fits perfect, premium leather, very comfortable

Nov 6, 2025
I ordered the roto shoulder holster with added ammo belt carry. I received my products after 30-days. These leather goods are exceptional. The craftsmanship is very impressive. Very high quality leather. The break-in oil helped to get my pistol to fit properly. I highly recommend you buy this kit to help make your firearm fit perfect. I had exceptional communication with craftholsters.com office staff through out my time waiting for delivery. If you're looking for high-end leather holster with exceptional craftsmanship. 1000% get these leather firearm products. You will not be disappointed. They have lots of YouTube videos on craftholsters.com.

This is for my Glock 30 .45 Auto. Not one holster in my closet serves all my carry needs. But this one applies to both concealed and ambi carry. As an ambi shooter, I appreciate the option in a single holster. I also have this same holster for a Ruger .357 Mag GP100 4.2" barrel. Both holsters conceal well, close to the body, with all day comfort under a loose shirt, even when both firearms are worn together, which I do sometimes when I'm plinking at the range. The weight of one or both firearms becomes virtually unnoticeable as long as you have a good stiff purpose-built belt. I have a number of Craft holsters for a variety of pistols and revolvers. These are well thought-out, ergonomic and durable pieces that will outlast me.

Fantastic leather holster. Great timely delivery!

Excellent hand crafted holsters custom made to fit. Repeat satisfied customer. I'm size XXL / XXXL Craft Holsters made shoulders holsters special for me that fit perfect!

This is a high quality, comfortable, beautiful holster. The roto system is phenomenal. If you want your firearm protected, well-secured and easy to draw, get a Craft holster.