Hagerty Reviews 

They're very affordable and knowledgeable If you have any questions

They have a creative way of charging in film when I advised I wanted to make payments, then she says “oh I charged your card for full payment!
Must be in financial trouble, I messed up by telling her I wanted to make minimum payment since I was looking somewhere else!

The big impression for me is they answer the phone you actually get to talk to someone and the someone you talk to is very knowledgeable about insurance in my case it happen to be Kamilah Abdullah.
Hagerty Insurance Company Best in the business

I’ve been a Hagerty customer for 15 years. This past month was my first claim. The claim process was very easy. I submitted pictures and video capture via the phone. The Hargerty team kept me updated via phone calls and emails throughout the entire process.

Get the price you want to pay for the coverage you need . Great company don’t spend funds that sit in your garage when you are driving your Baby

My husband and I have had several vehicles insured by Hagerty over a period of several years. My premiums have always been paid on time! There was never any lapse in insurance coverage. We live in FL and our vehicle was damaged/totaled during the back-to-back Hurricanes in 2024. We submitted a claim to Hagerty and even though we have a “guarantee pay policy”, they are denying the claim and not paying out. In addition, their appraiser came out to check the vehicle and stated the vehicle was no longer usable due to damage caused by the back-to-back storms in Florida. Again, Hagerty will not pay out. The vehicle was at a shop for some repairs and upgrades. We have provided pictures and had the owner of the auto repair shop give testimony and provided pictures. They still won’t pay out. Hagerty has no problem taking thousands of dollars from me in premiums but has every excuse as to why they don’t have to pay out for a legitimate claim. I have gotten an attorney involved and they refuse to respond to my attorney. I highly DO NOT recommend insuring your vehicle with Hagerty.

Affordability is key to keeping a weekend hobby out of reach for a small collector.

Easy to understand coverage and easy to apply online.

You provide excellent accessibility in the event of the need for claims.

Very helpful through communications of filing a claim. They were also very easy to deal with removing and adding vehicles to policy.

I got distracted when I was getting ready to leave from one of our cruise-ins and I forgot to secure my hood pins on my street rod and drove off. By the time I shifted into second gear I got a harsh reminder of what I had forgotten to do when the hood came up and slammed into my windshield. Needless to say I was absolutely sick about it and completely disgusted and disappointed with myself for doing something so dumb. Hagerty treated me with kindness and concern and never once made me feel like the idiot that I was and they took care of my claim from start to finish and now my car is actually better than it was before I forgot my pins. I’ve been with Hagerty for years and am very glad of it. I’m hoping to continue to be with them for many many more years to come!!

Good company, they’re actually real car people!! So they get how important our cars are to us!!

I've had several policies for various collector cars over the years. I just purchased a Corvette and my first thought was contacting Hagerty. We discussed limits and value and I was quoted $2391.65 for the year. TOO MUCH. I called NCM (National Corvette Museum) and for exactly the same policy, Im thrilled to be paying only....$518.00 per year!!! As an old customer, with never a claim, Im very disappointed in Hagerty Insurance.

I had hagerty for a about 3 years on my collector cars.
I never filed any claims, never had any tickets etc... My policy was about 7500 a year and everything was always good.
Then comes January 26 and I had identity theft. I have a police report and documentation for the incident.
Insurance was always paid automatically and no issues.
July 2026 comes for policy renewal and hagerty decides to raise my policy over $17,000. This raised my payment over $1000 from what it currently was ea h month.
I called them and come to find out why. Turns out they raised my policy due to bad credit.
I explained the situation and no one seemed to care or would do anything about it. Even with me having proper documentation and great history with them.
They simply woukd not do anything about it. Id have to dispute it with a 3rd party company.

After this I thought to my self. If I filed a claim, would Hagerty actually have my back?
After this incident and how Hagerty took care of me I wanted nothing to do with them.

I went to American collectors Insurance.
I Explained my situation. They took care of me. They even gave me a lower rate then I was paying with Hagerty.
I wasn't a customer to American collectors Insurance and they took
Care of me even with my current situation.
They had my back.

My 86 year old father was recently involved in an auto accident on 7/30/26. He contacted the claims department to file a claim on his vehicle that was totaled. Nadia Rodgers was handling his claim. Keep in mind, my father has zero technical abilities. The vehicle was towed to my licensed auto service facility. I was told by Nadia that Hagerty refuses to pay any storage fees which would have equated to 27 days at $50/day $1350 . I was also asked to send photos of the vehicle to aid in the claim. I sent complete photos on 3 separate occasions (8/3/26.8/5/26,8/25/26) and verbally asked for verification of receipt of those photos by both email and phone call. The emails contained all the photos as requested. Nadia informs my father that they only received 2 of those photos which is impossible since the email had all 6 photos as requested. She then told my father that I was not cooperating with the insurance company. It is not my job to handle their claim. She was rude and unprofessional. They should have sent out an adjuster to inspect the vehicle instead they expect someone else to do their job for them. Very displeased with this company.

Insured my classic car for three years. The policy lapsed, and they wouldn’t let me reinsure it so I could sell it. I guess being honest about why you want to insure a car is frowned upon? 😂

I called and canceled my insurance and they charged me NSF because they made a mistake and would not fix the problem !!

Hagerty understands classic and exotic cars are not daily drivers. Auto insurance rates are adjusted with this in mind. Also the weekly digital magazine has pertinent and excellent content with this in mind.