CJ Pony Parts Reviews 

I have purchased thousands of dollars in parts from CJ Pony for my 65 mustang and 73,75&77 Bronco’s. On September 4 I ordered a set of caps for 1973 mustang wheel that on site said in stock. I later saw they were not in stock and were on a back order. So I phoned them and asked when they would get them and they said they did not know they were back ordered at the factory. So I said cancel I will get them somewhere else. I then found them on E Bay and purchased them. On September 26 I found a transaction from CJ on my credit card and called them. I told them I had cancelled and stop the shipment. He left me on hold for 30 mins. Then came back and said sorry they have already been shipped. When they get to you just refuse the shipment and they will return to them and I would get a refund. I then found out that it was coming FedEx and did not require a signature. So I called FedEx to try and stop it and turn it around. They said only the shipper could do that….so why did they not do that off the hop????. The package showed up. 4 wheel caps 5”x3” in a box that is 3’ long 12” wide and 10” deep. No wonder shipping was so expensive. 40.00 US they have no concern for customer shipping costs…that is beside the point….now I have been requesting the return information since October 1st when it was delivered and still nothing. I have been back and forth with them. Very frustrating. This could have all been prevented if #1 they called the customer prior to sending out a back order to see if they even still wanted the items. #2 had of called FedEx and cancelled the shipment when I asked. Very frustrating after spending so much with these people they have lost my confidence and business going forward. I have contacted my credit card company and opened a dispute.

Dave

The customer service is totally garbage I paid almost 3000.00 for a carbon fiber trunk lid it's been a month trying to get a refund it's from Anderson composite and made very poorly nothing fits properly I would never buy another thing from cj Pony Parts.

I am super disappointed with them, bought hood hinge kit from them for a 65 mustang. The hinges were fine but the springs were absolute garbage and wouldn't even hold the hood up. That's not that big a deal but I tried to write a review on the product just to let people know, get better springs. We'll because it's not positive CJ won't post it. That's so dishonest.

Great parts but terrible service!!! I ordered around 1000 dollar in parts 4 months ago but the shipping is stuck at USPS... CJ just says: call them we can't do anything about that. Sure, called them USPS says: only sellers can start an investigation. Back to CJ, no response or the same standard reaction over and over again. I want my money back! Order number 71309369 in case anyone form CJ reads this... CONTACT ME!

Update 9/3: Barbara contacted me and is working on a solution.

Since we have a Mustang, we have been ordering our parts from CJPonyParts.
In the past I would rate 5 stars, good support, good products and fast delivery, but lately I don't know what's going on there, or what's going wrong at the warehouse. Wrong items delivered last time (resolved quickly), now received incomplete package...
Problems are resolved, although it took a while this time (little response to emails, took almost 4 weeks to be resolved).
My big thanks go to Barbara and Brad for their support on the last issue. The remainder of the package is expected within 1 week, hope (assuming) that it will be delivered correctly.

They sell crap parts that don’t fit and they won’t stand behind the parts. Buy from someone else.

the parts i order from the for my 69 c10 do not fit correctly, and i ordered some bumper bolts for the front bumper, and the nuts that came with it didnt even fit the bolts!, definitely wouldnt recommend ordering from them

ORDERED TRUNK MAT FOR MY 2014 MUSTANG CONVERTABLE AND WAS ASSURED IT WOULD FIT
OT DID NOT AND I HAVE TO PAY FOR SHIPPING FOR THEIR MIS TAKE

Korie Benson cj pony customer service rep. was very understanding and helpful.
I am restoring 65 mustang and ordered 4 chrome wheel well moldings 5 years ago.
Just last month I contacted Korie and explained one of them was mislabelled and did not fit... I sent photos . She requested.
Credit was promptly issued !
#664 9869
Thank you Korie!
Greg Sportun Mount hope Ontario Canada

I bought a brake booster set and when I installed it, it makes a hissing sound and is defective. I have sent all the information required for a reclamation on the 29-07-2024 and still haven't heard anything.
I have sent the requested information again on the 05-08-2024 and still haven't heard anything.

Can't recommend anyone buying their parts from this dealer, they don't care about their customers.

I ordered 2 door window crank handles. They sent me 1 right and 1 wrong. I asked for a return shipping label. never received. they wanted for me to pay to send it back. i told them that was their mistake. still never received. i told them, i would post bad reviews so they told me they would send. 30 days never received one. i restore cars and have spent so much money to be treated like this. if i were you i would not buy from them because if they send you the wrong part you will have to pay to have it sent back for their mistake. all of this for a $11.00 handle.

CJ Pony Parts (hereafter, CJPP) has been for many years one of my goto suppliers for parts, recommendations, and installation advice. Although this review highlights a poor experience with the package (packaging) and subsequent requests for redress regarding my most recent order from the company, it may not be representative of a more holistic evaluation of the current state of play at CJPP. I say this despite their TrustPilot rating which sits at 1.7 stars, the result of 73% 1-star and a mere 15% 5-star of ~177 reviews. With a A+ grade on the Better Business Bureau’s site, CJPP has earned 1.25 of 5 stars in customer feedback. Yelp finds CJPP a 1.3-stars over 281 reviews.

Recently, I ordered a set of Steeda Rear Subframe Support Braces (# 555-5754) from CJPP. I paid a total of $390.63, which included $38.06 for shipping and handling (provided by FedEx) of a package that arrived late, damaged, and with a part missing. The box, which appeared to be something they reused from previous returns (kudos for “recycling”), was crushed, perforated, and torn. Beyond that, a number of washers, one of which was missing, were scattered in the folds of the packing material. I cannot comment on why those washers were not included in the sealed pack of installation hardware that came with the braces–but reasonable speculation could posit that this set was a return CJPP simply taped back up and shipped out to me without a proper inspection beforehand. That probability would be supported by the condition of the box.

So, in total, the package was missing one washer. Some might say no big deal–an assessment with which I might tend to agree. That is, until I stopped to consider for what was I paying and why shouldn’t CJPP be given a chance to make good on such a menial failure.Well, that’s what I did.

I reached out to CJPP to inform them the box arrived in poor condition and to confirm that I did in fact have all the parts necessary for my installation to proceed. Maybe I only needed 7, not 8 washers, an idea I implied in my email by noting there was no inventory or instruction sheet with which I could have confirmed all the parts were included or not–an idea lost on their customer service representative. The response I received was concise or curt but certainly not helpful. I can’t read too much into the tone of the response which is absent any concern, never mind solution, but the interrogative at the end could be interpreted as a second-grade attempt at a sardonic quip.

“You appear to have all of the hardware with the exception of one washer. We have an installation video. Please see the below link?”

I replied in kind, “Ok, so I guess that means the kit is incomplete. Does CJ Pony have a remedy for this shortfall or am I off to the hardware store?”

Certainly, my concern doesn’t come near the expense and problems that others have faced. In fact, many might say the damage and missing parts are not worth the trouble to mention. But that’s not the sole measure of dissatisfaction here. It is, in a word, CJPP’s utter apathy.

UPDATE. CJPP responded: "We apologize for the inconvenience and if you could go to the hardware store that would be great. Please except this 10% code on items that apply for your future order."

Well, my view remains unchanged. Aside, does the phrase, "that would be great" ringa bell? Office Space.

Ordered parts on site, one part showing 2 week delay, came into stock but then 2 parts now out of stock but when check their website says parts are in East coast but not West coast. When Email they say they don't ship between their depots. 7 weeks later still waited. Asked to cancel the outstanding parts and I would reorder but informed all parts must ship together. Numerous emails and eventually cancelled those parts. Asked on one piece if clip and bearing included to be told No that's why was waiting on other parts. When order arrived the parts were actually included. They have no clue on items. Customer service reps are of no use and can't answer simple questions, that's if they actually respond to emails

Ordered parts to be shipped to the UK arrived within a few days. Paid customs charge up front which saved a lot of bother from my end. Will def order from them again.

Ordered 2 inside window crank handles with knobs. Received 1 correct handle and other one wrong. Set up to return part and they stated i would have to pay for shipping. I wrote 3 emails i needed a shipping label because it was their mistake for wrong part. I also told them i had ordered 2 handles and 2 black knobs. every time you try install the knobs they break because the plastic is so hard. so i ordered ones that had the knob already installed. but knob was clear. not what i wanted but would have to use due to knob breaking. I had also ordered 2 convertible top switch and both broke after one use so i put a 3 way toggle switch. The handle i received only costs around $11.00. why should i pay for shipping when it was their mistake. i sent a email that i am going to post bad reviews every where i can.1970 ford mustang. so if i was you do not order from CJ pony parts or you will get the wrong part and you will have to pay for shipping or buy 2 switch that break and they will not pay back because it was installed.

Purchased a set of Renegade Series Euro-Style taillights from them just under a year ago, one side already has moisture in it and the running lights are completely inoperable. Contacted them twice now pertaining to the aforementioned and both inquiries were deliberately ignored. I've now disputed the purchase and have submitted a consumer complaint pertinent to their products/etiquette to my respective Attorney General's office and the Federal Trade Commission. Also, don't buy their ACCELATEC Steering Wheels either, small pieces of the steering wheel have been coming off in my hand and the red stripe on the top of the steering wheel has also started staining various parts of my hand red. Their products appear to be cheap garbage, likely products that have been drop-shipped and marked up an egregious amount. Spend your money elsewhere, folks.

The vinyl floor mat that was delivered...was complete garbage . The shipping box was old and retaped several times! CJ Pony parts offered a RMA and stated I would have to pay the $50.00 in return shipping. Then upon arrival
at CJ Pony... THEY would decide on a refund or not! That means I get double dipped in $$$$ in shipping and have no parts!?!?!?

Found the parts I need .And delivery was quick.

Bought around $700 worth of parts to put my mustang back together including fender bolts and the special faster to hold the to the rocker. Guess which items I PAID FOR that were NOT in the box??? Yep. The fender bolts and the special one. Place is an absolute JOKE. Never have these issues with anyone else. Must be zero supervision there! Order number 71862903!

Absolute joke of an ordering system, I’ve spent a fortune on 3 mustang builds with them, this time I just ordered a load of parts half the orders I’m getting emails saying issues with billing address so orders cancelled please reorder, but they didn’t do it on all the orders so works for some but not others, tried 3 different cards again some orders worked but others didn’t. it’s because they take so long to process the order is what it looks like told them they sent me a refund on my last order as they didn’t like what I told then obviously no reply to my email as they must know how bad there ordering system, I’ll order from somewhere else made it an absolute headache